← The five-lens method

Incentives

How will everyone else respond?

Why it matters

People adjust when a rule changes what they are rewarded for, what they can see, or how much effort a path requires. A plan can meet its targets even as someone learns to work around its purpose. This lens treats those responses as foreseeable parts of the design.

Apply the lens

  1. Map the people and systems that can change the outcome. Include those doing exceptions work, anyone being measured, and those absorbing delays or cost.
  2. For each participant, compare the old and new choices, rewards, penalties and visibility. Look for behavior that makes sense for them but undermines the decision’s goal.
  3. Design a signal or rule that better aligns behavior with the objective. Consider where publishing the signal creates a new incentive to game it.

Questions to ask

  • Who benefits from getting just below a threshold?
  • What would make it easier to escalate a doubtful case than to pass it along?
  • What behavior would the dashboard celebrate even if the outcome got worse?

Worked example

If purchases under a cap clear automatically, teams may split a single order into smaller requests. The behavior can be rational even for responsible staff facing a tight deadline. The indicator to watch includes clusters of near-cap purchases, not just the number processed.

One test to run

Compare the distribution and grouping of requests around the proposed cap in a limited trial. Review a sample of near-cap clusters with procurement before deciding whether to change the rule.

What to capture

A stakeholder map, strategic interactions and the behaviors your plan may reward.

Explore the other lenses